14.04.2020, 13:41
This thread has been open long enough for everyone to chime in with an opinion if they so wished. Uwe and I have discussed each proposal and we have agreed to the following:
Proposal 1: RBs earn 0.5 points per reception
Verdict: We will not take this proposal to a vote, the impact of this change on the points system is too great and changes the identity of the league. We are not a half PPR league and don't wish to make such fundamental changes.
Proposal 2: Extend the Flex position to include TEs (thereby becoming Flex RB/WR/TE)
Verdict: This is a straightforward position eligibility proposal and therefore a simple majority is needed (7/12) to bring this rule into the 2020 season.*
Proposal 3: Change the waiver system from reverse order of the standings to a free agent auction
Verdict: This is a proposal that increases complexity for all owners and thus increases the time required during the waiver process, therefore a 75% majority is needed (9/12) to bring this rule into the 2020 season.*
Proposal 4: Add a second practice squad roster spot for rookies
Verdict: We will not take this proposal to a vote, one roster spot for rookies is sufficient.
*Caveat*: We have some concerns about the impact of proposal 2 and proposal 3 therefore if either proposal is passed it will be subject to a one-year trial period and re-evaluated after this period concludes.
The deadline for both polls is May 15 thus giving all owners 31 days to provide their response. Please message me directly when you've made your vote so I can ensure all owners have participated and can track down those that haven't before the deadline passes.
Proposal 1: RBs earn 0.5 points per reception
Verdict: We will not take this proposal to a vote, the impact of this change on the points system is too great and changes the identity of the league. We are not a half PPR league and don't wish to make such fundamental changes.
Proposal 2: Extend the Flex position to include TEs (thereby becoming Flex RB/WR/TE)
Verdict: This is a straightforward position eligibility proposal and therefore a simple majority is needed (7/12) to bring this rule into the 2020 season.*
Proposal 3: Change the waiver system from reverse order of the standings to a free agent auction
Verdict: This is a proposal that increases complexity for all owners and thus increases the time required during the waiver process, therefore a 75% majority is needed (9/12) to bring this rule into the 2020 season.*
Proposal 4: Add a second practice squad roster spot for rookies
Verdict: We will not take this proposal to a vote, one roster spot for rookies is sufficient.
*Caveat*: We have some concerns about the impact of proposal 2 and proposal 3 therefore if either proposal is passed it will be subject to a one-year trial period and re-evaluated after this period concludes.
The deadline for both polls is May 15 thus giving all owners 31 days to provide their response. Please message me directly when you've made your vote so I can ensure all owners have participated and can track down those that haven't before the deadline passes.
Trophy Case
IDFL 2015, 2017, 2020
NSFF 2018, 2022